Skip to product information
1 of 1

Plymouth Artisan Cheese Original Cheddar

Plymouth Artisan Cheese Original Cheddar

Regular price $11.99
Sale price $11.99 Regular price

4 left in stock!


Plymouth Artisan Cheese Original Cheddar is a true American classic.  Plymouth Cheese was originally founded by President Calvin Coolidge's family on their family dairy farm.  The Coolidge family's original recipe was discovered by cheese maker Jesse Werner taped to the walls of the old Plymouth factory.  

The cheddar is aged for one year.  This sharp full-bodied cheddar is said to be the closest modern-day cheddar to what the colonists enjoyed.  It has sharp tangy taste that is an amazing addition to any charcuterie board.  

We ship cheese based on delivery location. Shipment date will be decided based on best delivery date due to weather.  Cheese ships in an insulated pack via FedEx 2 Day shipping.



  • 8 oz. waxed.
  • Made in
  • Aged 1 year.
  • Raw Milk Cheese.

Care + Use

Store in

View full details

America's Oldest Cheddar

Plymouth Cheese Factory was created by President Coolidge's family in Plymouth, Vermont in 1890. In 2009, cheesemaker Jesse Warren started creating Plymouth Cheddar again with the original 1890's recipe that he found taped up in the barn. Enjoy a true American classic today.

Plymouth Cheese: Reviving a Brand